History
Where this comes from
Technomutualism joins two old ideas, mutualism and market socialism, to the problem of our time: the most powerful technology ever built, held by a few, used first to collect rent and now to watch and control. Here is the short story of each, and why the tools of the 2020s change what's possible.
Mutualism: equals helping equals
Mutualism is the idea that ordinary people can meet their needs by pooling what they have, as equals, without a boss or a charity in charge. The French thinker Pierre-Joseph Proudhon made the name famous in the 1840s, taking it from the silk workers of Lyon, who already called themselves mutualists. He imagined workers trading the fruits of their labour fairly through a "People's Bank" that would lend at almost no interest. But the practice is much older than the word.
- Always Burial clubs, harvest sharing, rotating savings circles. Across Africa, Asia and Latin America, many millions of people still save and borrow this way.
- 1827 Josiah Warren's Time Store in Cincinnati prices goods by the hours of work that went into them.
- 1832 Robert Owen's Labour Exchange in London lets craftspeople swap goods using "labour notes". It closes within two years, swamped by paperwork and by goods nobody wanted.
- 1844 The Rochdale Pioneers, a small group of working people in northern England, many of them weavers, open a shop owned by its customers. Their rules become the model for co-operatives worldwide.
- 1849 Proudhon's People's Bank signs up thousands of backers but raises little money, and is wound up as he is convicted and jailed for attacking the president in print.
- 1864 Friedrich Raiffeisen founds a rural credit co-operative in Germany. Today's credit unions, with hundreds of millions of members, descend from that idea.
- 1932 The Austrian town of Wörgl issues its own money in the Depression. Local projects get built and unemployment falls (how much is still debated), until Austria's national bank stops it in 1933.
- 1934 Swiss businesses start the WIR network: they give each other credit instead of borrowing from banks. It's still running nearly a century later.
- 1983 Michael Linton starts the first LETS, a local exchange trading system, in Canada's Comox Valley. Thousands follow worldwide in the 1990s.
- 1990s Slovenia runs a national service that clears loops of unpaid bills between businesses: if A owes B, B owes C and C owes A, the debts cancel out without any money changing hands. It still runs today.
- 2001 Argentina's barter clubs, started in 1995, boom during the economic collapse: millions of people trade through them. The clubs later fail, flooded by forged and over-printed paper credits.
- 2010 Sardex starts trading in Sardinia: thousands of local businesses go on to trade on mutual credit after the financial crisis.
The pattern repeats. Mutual projects work brilliantly at first, and then many hit the same walls.
The walls mutualism kept hitting
Bookkeeping
Every trade had to be written down, added up and posted to members by hand. LETS groups often depended on one or two volunteers, and many folded when those volunteers burnt out.
Forgery and over-printing
Paper credits can be copied, and whoever runs the press can print too many. That is what sank Argentina's barter clubs.
Trust in the bookkeeper
Members had to trust that whoever kept the books kept them honestly, with no way to check.
Distance
A group that worked in one town couldn't easily trade with the next one, so most stayed too small to matter.
Being shut down
From Proudhon's bank to Wörgl, projects that depended on one person or one licence were easy to stop.
Free riders
People who took credit and never gave back drained small groups, and nobody wanted the job of chasing them.
From rent to control: the problem we're answering
In 2020 the French economist Cédric Durand described the digital economy as techno-feudal. In 2023 Yanis Varoufakis went further in his book Technofeudalism: What Killed Capitalism.
His argument in short: the big platforms, such as Amazon, Apple, Google and Meta, are no longer markets but estates. In his account they own the land where buying, selling and talking happen; sellers pay a share of every sale to be allowed in; and users work for free, posting, rating and reviewing, which makes the platform more valuable. Varoufakis calls the owners' income cloud rent, and the rest of us cloud serfs.
Feudal lords didn't need to make the best product. They owned the land everyone had to use. That's the danger: not that technology is bad, but that whoever owns the platform owns everyone on it.
Rent was only the first stage. In 2019 Shoshana Zuboff's The Age of Surveillance Capitalism showed how the same companies turn what we do into predictions about what we will do, and sell them. Data gathered to sell us things is now fused with police and military systems, and some of the companies that sort our feeds now build software that sorts targets, for drones that increasingly choose for themselves.
In 2026 Naomi Klein and Astra Taylor gave the next stage a name in End Times Fascism: an alliance of tech billionaires, religious fundamentalists and ethno-nationalists that has given up on a shared future and plans who survives the collapse it helps bring on. Bunkers for the few, walls for everyone else.
Technomutualism answers every stage the same way: change who owns the land. Tools owned by the communities that use them can't be turned against those communities from the top, because there is no top to turn them.
What technology changes
Mutualism didn't lose ground because the idea was wrong. For two centuries, keeping the books, trusting strangers and settling trades between towns was slow and costly, and that cost favoured whoever could do it at scale: big banks and big companies. Software makes those jobs almost free, and the members can own it.
Each wall that stopped mutualism now has a technical answer that the members themselves can own:
Bookkeeping → software
A phone app records every trade the moment it happens and shows each member their own balance. No volunteer posts statements at midnight.
Forgery → signatures
Each payment is signed with a secret key only the payer holds. A forged payment simply fails the check: there is no paper to copy.
Over-printing → zero-sum credit
In mutual credit, every credit has a matching debit, so all balances always add up to zero. Nobody can print extra, because there is no printing press.
Trusting the bookkeeper → open code
The rules are open-source software. Anyone can read exactly how balances, limits and fees are calculated, and every change to the rules is public.
Distance → federation
Communities run their own servers and connect to each other over the internet, so a town in Australia can trade with one in Kenya without a central company in between.
Being shut down → copies everywhere
Open-source software can't be confiscated. If one server is closed, a community can restore its records elsewhere and carry on.
Free riders → earned limits
Credit limits grow with a member's trading record, so newcomers can't run up big debts and disappear.
And it can grow further. Communities that trade with each other could clear their loops of debt the way Slovenia does between businesses, so a town's surplus with one neighbour settles its debt with another.
None of these is magic, and none replaces good people. They take away the boring, error-prone and corruptible jobs that used to fall on a few volunteers, so the people can spend their energy on each other.
What software can't do
Software can keep honest books and connect communities. It can't grow food, make power or build homes. A community that trades in its own credit but still depends on distant suppliers for food, energy and tools only owns half of its economy.
The other half is physical: local food, shared tools and workshops, community energy, land held in common. That is where technomutualism has to grow next, and most of that work is still ahead of us.